Wednesday, October 23, 2024

Holmes, Marple, and Poe


This engaging read by James Patterson and Brian Sitts clearly draws some of the characters' idiosyncrasies from their namesakes. Brandon Holmes has a bit of a drug problem, Margaret Marple is British, and Auguste Poe has a haunted relationship with women and alcohol. Still the characters are distinct and fully developed in their own right and will be remembered as such. There are multiple mysteries here to be solved, some of them inter-related and some just puzzlingly unnecessary.  I tend to agree with Booklist's complaint that the book's "... biggest problem is the mysteries: there are too many of them. The investigators are juggling a bunch of cases, from a missing person to stolen art to a cold-case murder. The result? It's difficult for them and, unfortunately, the reader to focus on any individual case."

Three PI's renovate a warehouse in the Bushwick neighborhood of Brooklyn and with the help of "friends in high and low places" (Publishers Weekly), quickly solve the case of a missing high-profile attorney. This garners a lot of press and a certain amount of enmity among the police who have failed where "Holmes, Marple & Poe. Private Investigations" so quickly succeeded. Only one detective, Helene Grey, seems to appreciate their innovative and unorthodox methods of crime solving, and she becomes both an ally and a political target. 

Publishers Weekly calls this a "breezy thriller" with "short chapters and brisk prose [that] make for diverting-enough entertainment. This satisfies." I listened to the audio version and enjoyed 

No comments: