This "thriller" from Julia Phillips got such a glowing review from Kirkus that I really wanted to read it. But I found the minimal connections of each chapter's story and characters to the original crime to be increasingly frustrating. As I occasionally do when the light at the end of the tunnel seems to grow ever dimmer in a book, I jumped to the last chapter, and subsequently abandoned the book half-way through. I am including the review from Kirkus so you can see why I had such high hopes.
"A year in the lives of women and girls on an isolated peninsula in northeastern Russia opens with a chilling crime.
"A year in the lives of women and girls on an isolated peninsula in northeastern Russia opens with a chilling crime.
In
the first chapter of Phillips' immersive, impressive, and strikingly
original debut, we meet sisters Alyona and Sophia, ages 11 and 8,
amusing themselves one August afternoon on the rocky shoreline of a
public beach on the waterfront of Petropavlovsk-Kamchatsky, a city on
Russia's remote Kamchatka peninsula. They are offered a ride home by a
seemingly kind stranger. After he drives right past the intersection
that leads to the apartment they share with their mother, they disappear
from their previous lives and, to a large extent, from the narrative.
The rest of the book is a series of linked stories about a number of
different women on the peninsula, all with the shadow of the missing
girls hanging over them as a year goes by since their disappearance.
Another young girl with a single mom loses her best friend to new
restrictions imposed by the other girl's anxious mother. The daughter of
a reindeer herder from the north, at college in the city, finds her
controlling boyfriend clamping down harder than ever. In a provincial
town, members of a family whose teenage daughter disappeared four years
earlier are troubled by the similarities and differences between their
case and this one. The book opens with both a character list and a
map—you'll be looking at both often as you find your footing and
submerge ever more deeply in this world, which is both so different from
and so much like our own. As the connections between the stories pile
up and tighten, you start to worry—will we ever get closure about the
girls? Yes, we will. And you'll want to start over and read it again,
once you know.
An unusual, cleverly constructed
thriller that is also a deep dive into the culture of a place many
Americans have probably never heard of, illuminating issues of race,
culture, sexual attraction, and the transition from the U.S.S.R. to
post-Soviet Russia."
No comments:
Post a Comment